Finance Terms: 12B-1 Fee

A stack of coins with a dollar sign on top

If you’re considering investing in a mutual fund, you’ve probably come across the term “12B-1 fee.” It’s one of the many fees associated with mutual funds, and it can have a significant impact on your overall investment costs. In this article, we’ll explore what the 12B-1 fee is, how it works, and whether it’s worth paying for.

What is the 12B-1 Fee and How Does It Work?

The 12B-1 fee is a type of mutual fund fee that is charged to investors for ongoing expenses like marketing and distribution. This fee is named after the SEC rule that established it, which was enacted in 1980. Essentially, the 12B-1 fee allows mutual fund companies to use a portion of their assets to cover marketing costs, advertising, and other expenses related to the ongoing distribution of their mutual funds.

The 12B-1 fee is an annual fee, usually charged as a percentage of the fund’s assets, that is deducted from the fund’s returns. The exact percentage of the 12B-1 fee can vary from fund to fund, but it’s usually between 0.25% – 1% of the fund’s net asset value (NAV). The NAV is the total value of the mutual fund’s assets, minus any liabilities, divided by the number of shares outstanding. This means that the 12B-1 fee will increase as the value of the fund’s assets increase.

It’s important to note that the 12B-1 fee is not the only fee associated with mutual funds. Investors may also be charged other fees, such as management fees, administrative fees, and transaction fees. These fees can vary depending on the mutual fund and the investment company.

Investors should carefully review the fees associated with any mutual fund they are considering investing in. While the 12B-1 fee may seem small, it can add up over time and impact the overall return on investment. It’s important to understand all of the fees associated with a mutual fund and to consider them when making investment decisions.

The History of the 12B-1 Fee

The 12B-1 fee was introduced by the SEC in 1980 as a way to help investors gain access to no-load mutual funds. A no-load mutual fund is a fund that doesn’t charge a traditional sales load fee (i.e., a commission) when investors buy or sell shares. Instead, no-load funds charge their investors ongoing fees, such as the 12B-1 fee, to cover these costs.

In the years since its introduction, the 12B-1 fee has become a significant source of revenue for mutual fund companies. According to Morningstar, mutual fund investors paid $9.5 billion in 12B-1 fees in 2020 alone. While the fee was originally intended to help investors gain access to no-load funds, it’s now a common fee charged by both no-load and load mutual funds.

Understanding the Different Types of Mutual Fund Fees

Mutual funds charge investors a variety of fees, all of which can impact an investor’s overall investment costs. Some of the most common types of mutual fund fees include:

  • Management fees: These are fees charged to cover the cost of running the mutual fund, including research, analysis, and administrative expenses. Management fees are usually charged as an annual percentage of the fund’s assets.
  • 12B-1 fees: As we’ve discussed, 12B-1 fees are charged to cover ongoing expenses related to marketing and distribution. These fees are usually charged annually as a percentage of the fund’s assets.
  • Sales load fees: These are fees charged to investors when they buy or sell shares in a mutual fund. Sales load fees can be front-end, meaning they are charged when an investor buys shares, or back-end, meaning they are charged when the investor sells shares.

In addition to these fees, mutual funds may also charge investors other fees, such as account maintenance fees or redemption fees. It’s essential to understand all the fees that a mutual fund charges before investing, as they can significantly impact your overall investment returns.

It’s important to note that some mutual funds may also charge performance fees. These fees are based on the fund’s performance and are typically charged as a percentage of the fund’s returns. Performance fees are designed to incentivize fund managers to achieve strong returns, but they can also significantly impact an investor’s overall costs. It’s crucial to carefully review a mutual fund’s prospectus to understand all the fees associated with the fund before investing.

Comparing 12B-1 Fees to Other Mutual Fund Fees

When considering whether to invest in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee, it’s essential to compare it to other mutual fund fees. For example, some funds charge a front-end load fee, which can be as high as 5.75% of the amount invested. This means that if you invest $10,000 in a mutual fund with a front-end load fee of 5.75%, $575 of your investment would go towards paying the sales commission.

Other mutual funds may charge a back-end load fee, which is levied when an investor sells their shares. While back-end load fees may be lower than front-end load fees, they can still be a significant expense for investors who want to sell their shares in the short term.

Compared to these fees, the 12B-1 fee may seem less significant. However, it’s essential to remember that the 12B-1 fee is an ongoing fee that is deducted from the fund’s returns every year. Over time, this fee can add up and significantly impact an investor’s overall investment returns.

The Pros and Cons of Investing in Mutual Funds with a 12B-1 Fee

When deciding whether to invest in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee, there are several pros and cons to consider. Some potential benefits of investing in a fund with a 12B-1 fee include:

  • No initial sales charge: Unlike front-end load mutual funds, which charge investors a commission when they buy shares, no-load mutual funds and funds with a 12B-1 fee don’t charge an initial sales charge. This means that investors can put their entire investment into the fund, rather than paying a portion as a commission.
  • Access to professional management: Mutual funds are managed by professional investment managers who have experience analyzing and selecting stocks or other securities. Investors who don’t have the time or inclination to manage their investments may benefit from investing in a mutual fund.
  • Diversification: Mutual funds are often diversified, which means they invest in a range of securities across multiple industries. This can help reduce an investor’s risk compared to investing in individual securities.

However, there are also some potential downsides to investing in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee, including:

  • Expense: As we’ve discussed, the 12B-1 fee is an ongoing fee that’s deducted from the fund’s returns annually. Over time, this fee can significantly impact an investor’s returns, especially if they hold the fund for a long time.
  • Lack of control: When investing in a mutual fund, investors don’t have control over individual stock selections or other security choices. Instead, the fund’s management team makes investment decisions on behalf of the investors. This means that investors may not be able to achieve their specific investment goals or preferences through the mutual fund.
  • Active management: Mutual funds are often actively managed, meaning that the fund’s management team buys and sells securities in an attempt to beat the market. This can result in higher expenses and higher fees compared to passively managed funds like index funds.

Another potential downside to investing in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee is the potential for conflicts of interest. Since the fund’s management team is compensated based on the assets under management, they may be incentivized to prioritize growing the fund’s assets over making investment decisions that are in the best interest of the investors. This can lead to investment decisions that benefit the fund’s management team more than the investors.

How to Calculate Your Total Investment Costs with a 12B-1 Fee

When investing in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee, it’s essential to calculate your total investment costs to understand how much of your investment will go towards fees. Here’s an example:

You invest $10,000 in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee of 1%. Over the course of the year, the fund generates a return of 7%, bringing the fund’s total value to $10,700. If the 12B-1 fee is charged on an annual basis, the fee would be $107 (1% of $10,700). This means that your investment earnings would be $593 ($700 – $107) for the year.

This example shows that the 12B-1 fee can have a significant impact on your investment returns, even if it seems like a small percentage. Before investing in a mutual fund, be sure to calculate your total investment costs to understand how much of your earnings will go towards fees.

It’s important to note that the 12B-1 fee is not the only fee associated with mutual funds. Other fees may include management fees, administrative fees, and transaction fees. These fees can add up quickly and significantly impact your investment returns.

One way to minimize the impact of fees on your investment returns is to invest in low-cost index funds. These funds typically have lower fees than actively managed funds and can provide similar returns over the long term.

How to Find Low-Cost Mutual Funds with No 12B-1 Fees

If you’re concerned about paying 12B-1 fees or other mutual fund fees, you may be able to find low-cost mutual funds that don’t charge these fees. One option is to invest in index funds, which are passively managed funds that track a specific market index (like the S&P 500). Because index funds aren’t actively managed, they tend to have lower fees compared to actively managed funds.

Another option is to invest in no-load mutual funds, which don’t charge front-end load fees. While no-load funds may still charge a management fee and other fees, not having to pay a sales commission can reduce an investor’s overall costs.

It’s important to note that while low fees are important, they shouldn’t be the only factor you consider when choosing a mutual fund. You should also consider the fund’s investment strategy, performance history, and the fund manager’s experience and track record. Additionally, it’s important to regularly review your investments and make adjustments as needed to ensure your portfolio aligns with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Common Misconceptions about 12B-1 Fees

There are several common misconceptions about 12B-1 fees that are worth addressing:

  • 12B-1 fees only apply to no-load funds: While 12B-1 fees were originally intended to help investors access no-load mutual funds, they are now charged on both no-load and load funds.
  • 12B-1 fees are a one-time charge: 12B-1 fees are an ongoing expense that is charged annually as a percentage of the fund’s assets.
  • 12B-1 fees are illegal: While some investors may view 12B-1 fees as unnecessary, they are a legal fee that is disclosed to investors in a mutual fund’s prospectus.

Another common misconception about 12B-1 fees is that they are used to compensate financial advisors. While it is true that some financial advisors receive a portion of the 12B-1 fee as compensation for their services, this is not always the case. In fact, some mutual funds use the 12B-1 fee to cover marketing and distribution expenses.

It is also important to note that 12B-1 fees can vary widely from one mutual fund to another. Some funds may charge a 12B-1 fee of 0.25%, while others may charge as much as 1%. As an investor, it is important to carefully review a mutual fund’s prospectus to understand the fees and expenses associated with the fund.

The Relationship Between the SEC and 12B-1 Fees

As we’ve discussed, the 12B-1 fee was created by the SEC to help investors access no-load mutual funds. However, in recent years, the SEC has taken steps to evaluate whether 12B-1 fees are in the best interests of investors.

In 2018, the SEC proposed a new rule that would modernize the regulation of mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). As part of this proposed rule, the SEC would require mutual funds to disclose more information about their fees, including expenses associated with marketing and distribution (i.e., 12B-1 fees).

While the SEC’s new rule has not yet gone into effect, it’s a sign that regulators are paying attention to mutual fund fees and the impact they have on investors.

Additionally, the SEC has also been exploring the possibility of eliminating or reducing 12B-1 fees altogether. In a 2018 speech, SEC Chairman Jay Clayton stated that the SEC was considering whether 12B-1 fees were still necessary and effective in today’s market. This has led to speculation that the SEC may eventually phase out 12B-1 fees, which could have significant implications for the mutual fund industry and investors.

Strategies for Reducing Your Investment Costs with a 12B-1 Fee

If you’ve decided to invest in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee, there are several strategies you can use to reduce your investment costs:

  • Invest in low-cost funds: Low-cost mutual funds, including index funds and no-load funds, tend to have lower fees compared to actively managed funds. Investing in these funds can help reduce your overall investment costs.
  • Shop around: Before investing in a mutual fund, compare its fees to other funds in the same category. Look for funds with lower fees or no 12B-1 fees to reduce your costs.
  • Consider passively managed funds: Passively managed funds like index funds tend to have lower fees compared to actively managed funds. If you’re comfortable with an investment strategy that focuses on tracking an index, consider investing in passive funds.

Another strategy to reduce your investment costs with a 12B-1 fee is to invest for the long term. Mutual funds with 12B-1 fees are designed for long-term investors, and the fees are typically lower for investors who hold their shares for a longer period of time. By holding your shares for a longer period, you can reduce the impact of the 12B-1 fee on your overall investment returns.

Conclusion: Is Paying a 12B-1 Fee Worth It?

Ultimately, the decision to invest in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee is up to the investor. While these fees can help mutual fund companies cover their marketing and distribution expenses, they can also significantly impact an investor’s overall investment returns.

Before investing in a mutual fund with a 12B-1 fee, be sure to understand all the fees associated with the fund and calculate your total investment costs. Consider low-cost funds, passively managed funds, and other strategies for reducing your investment costs.

By doing your research and making an informed decision, you can invest in mutual funds in a way that aligns with your financial goals and objectives.

It’s important to note that not all mutual funds charge a 12B-1 fee. Some funds may charge a different type of fee, or no fee at all. It’s important to compare the fees of different funds before making a decision.

Additionally, it’s important to consider the performance of the mutual fund in question. A fund with a 12B-1 fee may have strong performance that justifies the fee, while a fund with no fee may have poor performance that makes it a less attractive investment.

Related Posts

Annual Vet Bills: $1,500+

Be Prepared for the unexpected.